Hai Le

Social Media Marketing and Web Analytics

Vietnam Online Explosion Cimigo SDM 2009

leave a comment »

View Mode Scroll Book Slideshow Zoom
2 / 68

Written by leminhhai

04.12.2009 at 02:51

Posted in reseach

Tagged with , ,

The Value of Reputation

leave a comment »

7-reputation-dimensions

A few days ago, I published the chart you see in this post on Twitter to highlight how one of my favorite brands, Nutella, has the best global reputation across the board. The Reputation Institute, which was introduced to me by my friend Richard Binhammer over a year ago, pulls together seven dimensions to compute a brand’s reputation.

They are:

  • product/service
  • innovation
  • workplace
  • governance
  • citizenship
  • leadership
  • performance

How many of you are actively working on communicating with the people and communities that contribute to influencing your brand’s reputation across these seven dimensions? Customers, employees, partners, investors, and so on.

You know that reputation has an impact on the perceived value of your company and brand.

Yet so many companies do a poor job at providing a diverse image across these dimensions, especially on a proactive basis. Underestimating the fact that a strong platform of support is not just necessary, it is a vital part of the brand’s present and future performance.

Therein lies the difference between risk management, a discipline of good and proactive practices that help you identify, assess, implement, and measure activities that allow the organization to be proactive and strategic about risk, and crisis management, its reactive cousin.

Why this is important

Many companies tend to react to crisis and very rarely work on a thought out plan to minimize risks. Is it any wonder that the PR profession is so active around crisis communications today?  Danah Boyd’s Web 2.0 Expo flow of information talk provides a set of data points on how to go about it today [hat tip Neil Perkin].

Information sites used to be a destination, accessing information a process, producing content a task – things are now in constant flow. How has flow transformed the production of and attention to information? Wearing the public relations and communications hat, and thinking about the dimensions of company and brand reputation, here’s why this is an important consideration.

To be relevant today requires understanding context, popularity, and reputation.

Making content work in a networked era is going to be about living in the streams, consuming and producing alongside “customers.” Consuming to understand, producing to be relevant.

Content creators are not going to get to dictate the cultural norms just because they can make their content available; they are still accountable to those who are trafficking content.

We need technological innovations. For example, tools that allow people to more easily contextualize relevant content regardless of where they are and what they are doing and tools that allow people to slice and dice content so as to not reach information overload.

This is not simply about aggregating or curating content to create personalized destination sites.

Recommendation and Reputation
How are you engaging content mediators and information networkers across the dimensions that form your brand’s reputation? Remember that reputation and recommendation are tightly correlated.

What it may look like

Here are some initial ideas for each of the seven dimensions, taking into consideration that monitoring and listening is part of the consuming activity, as well as the producing. The beauty of flow – and its inherent scariness – is that it is ongoing, at times rapid, and ever changing.

Consider:

  • product/service [classified as key driver at 17.5%] – product development and customer service teams need to get integrated in the flow to understand uses and issues. Are your products and services high quality?
  • governance [classified as key driver at 15.1%] – board of directors, management, employees, suppliers, customers, banks and other lenders, regulators, the environment and the community at large all reach a common understanding.
  • citizenship [classified as key driver at 14.7%] – also known as corporate social responsibility is where management and business strategists need to connect with the responsibility for the impact of the company’s activities on the environment, consumers, employees, communities, stakeholders, etc.
  • innovation – product development, marketing, and business strategy are synchronized in real time to capture feedback loops.
  • workplace – business strategists, human resources personnel, managers especially embedded in the collaboration networks. Are you treating employees well? With a simple link or comment thread, the world will know instantly.
  • leadership – executive and management behavior not shielded from but exposed to the flow and vice versa. Good leadership increases trust, confidence, support, and investment from key stakeholders. Emotional investment, especially at a time when companies are losing trust so rapidly, creates economic value. Are you practicing transparent and ethical business?
  • performance – investors are also employees, customers, and partners. Their experience and understanding impacts the company’s performance today more than ever. Is the company’s vision articulated clearly? Is the company delivering on its financial expectations?

There is an ever stronger correlation between recommendation and reputation. According to the Institute’s research, if you improve reputation by 5 points, support goes up by 6.75%. Ferrero, IKEA, and Johnson & Johnson have the best global reputation in the chart above. Which means:

  1. customers trust what the company is promising
  2. investors can count on financial predictions
  3. employees know the company will honor its word
  4. the world admires the company’s leadership

This is where communications and social become operational, with communicators curating the conversation, connecting the dots, and working alongside teams while maintaining a direct line to company officers and executives.

Does this give you a few ideas on the changing role of public relations professionals? How are you organizing to be in the stream to help curate the conversation with stakeholders and fulfill the brand and company’s reputation needs across its dimensions?

***

Note on survey methodology: companies were rated by customers in their home country. The Global Reputation Pulse (your info required to download) is a measure of corporate reputation calculated by averaging perceptions of trust, esteem, admiration, and good feeling obtained from a representative sample of 100 local respondents who were familiar with the company.

_______

Further reading on reputation:

Improve Your Company’s Reputation Online

Conversational Index is Reputation-Driven

Reputation, the One Thing You Cannot Really Buy

© 2006-2009 Valeria Maltoni. All rights reserved.

Written by leminhhai

30.11.2009 at 00:11

Posted in brand

Tagged with ,

Google Adwords Certification Vs Google Analytics Qualified

leave a comment »

Posted by immanuelruby on March 12, 2009 · Filed Under AdwordsGoogle Analyticsppc

In today’s economic season, website decision making plays vital role in Marketing and Advertising industry. Keeping this in mind, recently Google has announced certification entitled “Google Analytics Qualified”. As we all know about Google Adwords certification known as “Individual Google Adwords Professional” that you and/or your company has a good understanding of how the Adwords system works. It’s good for the resume, as well as another level of accreditation.
Here I have described the similarities and differences on how to take test, study materials and other details on Google Adwords Certification and Google Analytics Qualified.

 

Details Google Adwords Certification Google Analytics Qualified
Announced Well known to all long before It has been launched just last month
Exam Fee $50.00 $50.00
Pass % 75.00% 75.00%
Name of the Certification Will be registered as “Google Adwords Qualified Professional” Will be registered as “Google Analytics Qualified”
Validity Period Remains current for 36 months from the date that you pass the test. Remains current for 18 months from the date that you pass the test.
Study Materials You can find it on Google Adwords Learning center. All content is freely available for you to access online via Conversion University.
Study Material – Type Both Multimedia and Text lessons Adobe presentation
Eligibility Manage at least one AdWords account (yours or someone else’s) in My Client Center for 90 days. No need to have a website with Google Analytics installed in order to become qualified in Google Analytics
Build and maintain at least US$1,000 total spend for your or your team’s My Client Center account during the 90-day period.
Cost of Materials Free Free
After passing the Exam Once you achieve your certification, you can use it in promotional materials for your company. You’ll be effective at leveraging Google Analytics within your organization and helping others to do the same.

 

Disclaimer: The post is completely based on individual thoughts and SEO Services Group bears no responsibilities for the thoughts reflected in the post.

Written by leminhhai

29.11.2009 at 13:36

Posted in marketing

Tagged with , ,

Why Are Marketers So Bad At Measuring Social Media? (And How Can They Get Better?)

leave a comment »

Why Are Marketers So Bad At Measuring Social Media? (And How Can They Get Better?)

Nate Elliott

NOVEMBER 02, 2009

[Posted by Nate Elliott. Follow me on twitter.]

Marketers don’t think they’re very good at measuring social media.  When my colleague Emily Riley asked marketers to rate their ability to measure the impact of their social media initiatives, the average grade they gave themselves was 4.5 out of 10. Not a great score — especially given that accountability is one of the key selling points of interactive marketing. So I’ve spent a lot of time this year trying to understand why marketers aren’t good at measuring social media — and how they can do better.

The fact is, social media marketers are drowning in a sea of metrics. Every social platform and vendor offers its own metrics, and there are literally hundreds of ways to measure the success of social initiatives. With so many numbers to choose from, and so little insight into which metrics are important, it’s not surprising that marketers feel overwhelmed.

Most marketers fixate on easily-available measures like followers or fans — regardless of whether those metrics are important. Many others fail to measure obviously useful numbers just because they’re not on the first page of a report. A marketer focused ontalking [video] should have a radically different definition of success than one focused on embracing [video]. But marketers are much more likely to tailor their social media measurement to the tools they’re using than to the objectives they’re trying to achieve. Have a look — most marketers measure pretty much the same metrics, no matter what their objective:

3steps

It’s obvious that marketers need more clarity into which social media metrics they should be tracking. So we’ve developed a simple three-step process to help marketers better tailor their measurement strategies to the objectives they’re pursuing. Walking through these three steps will help you cut through the clutter on your marketing reports and measure your social media initiatives more effectively:

  • Step 1: Think back to your marketing objective. Go back and find your notes from when you were first planning your social marketing effort — and remind yourself of the objective you were pursuing. If you don’t know what your goal was, you’ll never know what you should be measuring, or if you succeeded.
  • Step 2: Consider what types of metrics signal success. Don’t think about specific lines on a report yet — instead, think about what types of consumer behaviors and sentiments match your objectives, and focus your measurement on those categories of metrics. If your goal was energizing, success is defined as lots of people saying positive things about your brand; if your goal was supporting, you want to know if users were providing good advice to each other — and whether it kept users from having to ask you for support directly.  Again, this isn’t about specific metrics, it’s about how you hoped your social initiative would change your relationship with consumers.
  • Step 3: Look for that category of metric in the social technology you’re using. Once you’ve identified the type of metric that will signal success, then you can look for ways to track those metrics within the social platform you’re using. This is when you should get into the specifics of which lines on the report Facebook or Jive gives you are most important — and which other vendors you need to use to find the exact numbers you’re looking for.

In my new report, ‘Three Steps To Measuring Social Media Marketing,’ I offer a framework that helps marketers place social media metrics into one of six categories, shows them which categories of metrics should be used to measure which objectives, and gives examples of how to obtain those metrics from each social platform. I hope clients use my framework; I think it will make their lives easier and their measurement more successful.

But the key message of that report (and this blog post) isn’t the framework, it’s this call to action: We as an industry must do better at measuring social media marketing. Social media budgets keep rising, but that trend won’t continue forever if we can’t prove that social initiatives are effective. Perhaps more important, if we don’t know which social applications succeeded and which didn’t, we can’t learn from our experiences and improve on future efforts. And it’s surprisingly easy to measure social media effectively: we just need to focus on measuring objectives rather than technologies.

Whether you use the detailed framework in my report, or simply keep these three steps in mind as you design your own measurement strategy, I hope these ideas help you sift through all the social media metrics that are available, and find the right ones to measure your efforts.

Written by leminhhai

29.11.2009 at 02:23

Posted in social media

Tagged with ,

Evolution: The Eight Stages Of Listening

leave a comment »

Evolution: The Eight Stages Of Listening

Categories: Analysis, Social CRM, Social MediaPosted on November 10th, 2009

As Social Customers Become More Empowered, Organizations Must Have A Listening Strategy
As we approach 2010 planning companies need a strategy around listening. Sadly, most companies, and their agency partners don’t know why to listen or how. As a result, they must identify which stage of listening they are at, and then set a goal on which stage they see to aspire in 2010. I originally published this matrix for client workshops and a keynote presentation on developing listening and advocacy programs, and I’m going to continue to share more and blow-out each of my slides.

Web Strategy Matrix: The Eight Stages Of Listening

Stage Description Resources Needed Impacts
1) No objective at all Organization has a listening program but has no goals, nor uses the information for anything resourceful Simple alerting tools, like Google Alerts and feedreaders will suffice. At the basic level, simple self-awareness.  Yet without any action from the data, this is useless.
2) Tracking of brand mentions Like traditional “clip reports” of media relations, companies now track mentions in the social space.  Despite tracking there is no guidance on what to do next. Listening platform with report capability based on brand or product keywords.  Radian 6, Visible Technologies, Techrigy/Alterian, Buzzmetrics and Cymfony, Dow Jones are providers. Improved self-awareness to track volume of information, yet unable to track depth, and tonality of conversations.  As a result, not a full understanding of opportunities.
3) Identifying market risks and opportunities This proactive process involves seeking out discussions online that may result in identifying flare-ups, or possible prospect opportunities. In addition to a listening platform staff must actively seek out discussions and signal to internal teams.  Alerting tools, and listening platforms are required. Organization can reduce risk of flare ups before they become mainstream, identify prospects and poach unhappy competitors customers.
4) Improving campaign efficiency Rather than just measure a marketing effort after it’s occurred, using tools to gauge during in-flight behavior yields real-time marketing efficiency. Dedicated resource to manage reactions, activity, and sentiment to a marketing effort, and the resources to make course corrections nearly real-time.  Traditional web analytics tools like Omniture, Webtrends and Google Analytics are common. Campaigns can be more effective, as hot spots are bolstered, and dead spots are diminished.
5) Measuring customer satisfaction In addition to customer satisfaction scores,organizations can measure real-time sentiment as customers interact. Sysomos and Backtype have focus areas into this space. Customer experience professionals will have to extend their scope to the social web, using a listening platform and sentiment analysis.  Insight platforms like Communispace and Passenger offer online focus groups solutions. Brands can now measure impacts of real time satisfaction or frustration during the actual phases of customer interaction.  Then identify areas of improvement during customer lifecycle
6) Responding to customer inquiry This proactive response finds customers where they are (fish where fish are) in order to answer questions.  Example: Comcastcares account on Twitter asks customers if they need help –then may respond. An active customer advocacy team that’s empowered, training, and ready to make real-time responses nearly around the clock. Customers will fill a greater sense of satisfaction, yet this teaches customers to ‘yell in public’ to get a response.
7) Better understand customers Evolving the classic market research function, brands can improve their customer profiles and personas by adding social information to them. Social CRM systems are quickly emerging that tie together a customer record and their online behavior, locations, and preferences. Salesforce, SAP, both have partnerships with Twitter to synch data The opportunity to not only serve customers in their natural mediums, but to offer them a richer experience regardless of their customer touchpoints.
8. Being proactive and anticipating customers Minority Report: This most sophisticated form actually anticipates what customers will say or do before they’ve done it.  By looking at previous patterns of historical data, companies can put in place the right resources to guide prospects and customers. An advanced customer database, with a predictive application put in place, as well as a proactive team to reach out to customers before an incident has happened.  Haven’t seen any such application yet. Identifying prospects and engaging them before competitors can yield a larger marketing funnel, or reducing customer frustration as problems are fixed before they happen.


Exercise: Self-Assess Culture, Roles, Process, Data, and Tools

Use this matrix to initiate a discussion within your company on which stage you’re at, then put a plan in place to grow to the next level. Do note, depending on size and complexity of the organization, different groups may be in more than one phase. First, identify the characteristics your company currently has, then define which phase you’re in:

  1. Does the organization have the right culture setup that’s ready to listen?
  2. Is the organization prepared to react to customer opinions? how about in real time?
  3. Are the processes in place to triage information to the right teams? How about during a real-time crises on a Saturday morning?
  4. Are the right roles in place to listen? Are proactive marketing and support teams trained, empowered, and ready to respond?
  5. Is there a single repository of customer information or is it currently fragmented around the enterprise
  6. Lastly, what technology platforms are in place to facilitate this strategy? ? Hint: choose this last –not first.

For Dialog: Which Stage Are Companies At?
Curious to hear your professional opinions, what stage do most companies think they’re at?  In reality, what stage are they truly acting at?

Written by leminhhai

25.11.2009 at 12:42

Posted in crm

Tagged with ,

McDonald’s Social Media Marketing Strategy

leave a comment »

McDonald’s Social Media Marketing Strategy

Written by Marc Metekohy on November 23rd, 2009 |

There is virtually noone in the industrialized world who has not been to McDonald’s at least once in his or her lifetime. The global market leader on fast food has recently shared its view on Social Media Marketing Strategy and what it means for McDonald’s and how they want to become market leader in this area as well.

Heather Oldani, U.S. Communications Director at McDonald’s, has shared McDonald’s Social Media Marketing Strategy and is a must-read for CMO’s.

Important to McDonald’s are the following key learnings:

  1. Ask yourself…”How can we actively engage” vs “Should we engage?”
  2. Walk before running…Develop the right strategy for your brand vs leaping into tactical activation
  3. Collaborate…Social media has potential for a number of different departments within a company
  4. Be flexible/nimble…Some new trend that has the potential to impact your brand is always around the corner
  5. Be open to feedback…Everyone has an opinion about your brand, products, services so be open and willing  to listen

It is interesting to see the different means used in collaboration with each other, from Twitter to Facebook to their own HUB.

Congratulations to Heather in achieving this great social strategy.

Written by leminhhai

24.11.2009 at 19:08

Posted in strategy

Tagged with , ,

What’s creative

leave a comment »

What’s Creativeness?

In the dictionary, it likes that

cre·a·tive (krē-ā’tĭv)
adj.

  1. Having the ability or power to create: Human beings are creative animals.
  2. Productive; creating.
  3. Characterized by originality and expressiveness; imaginative:creative writing

Community

Many people think that creativeness is smt great and it’s an innate character

My way

But I think that isn’t a perfect definition. That’s too old and not enough. In my opinion and other people love trizism,

Creativeness is a process that create something news and it has benefits.

Why it’s more perfect?

As a marketer, I fell the liking between creative and marketing major.

new       =    different

benefit =    get achievement


 

Written by leminhhai

23.11.2009 at 17:32

Posted in creative

Tagged with ,

The Future of Agencies: What Do You Think?

leave a comment »

[Posted by David Cooperstein]

Follow me @minicooper

We’re in the process of pondering a very important question in the industry today: what is the future of agencies? Agencies have played such a crucial role in helping companies market their products and services for more than a century. Names like McCann Erickson, Young & RubicamJ. Walter Thompson,Ogilvy & Mather, and Saatchi & Saatchi (among others) are practically household names. There’s even a massively popular and critically acclaimed television showcapturing life in the golden age of legendary agencies on Madison Avenue.

Yet the agency model was built during a time when there were only a handful of channels in which they could push one way messages en masse. Does that model still work in a time when nearly a quarter of online US adults now create content online? Many more questions begin to arise as we open Pandora’s Box: Can one agency do it all? Are holding companies the answer? Can digital agencies compete with them and lead brands? Do marketers rely on agencies like they used to? Should marketers consolidate their agencies or de-centralize to dozens of agency partners? Are technology providers and crowd sourcing legitimate threats? Where is this all going?

To conduct this research we’re speaking with some of the most influential agencies, marketers, and service providers. However, what better way to get a feel for the pulse of the industry than to crowd source it? So we’re reaching out to get your take on the space. Please give us your thoughts in the comments section on the question: What is the future of agencies?

We look forward to your input from the Marketing Leader’s perspective (and please try to keep it to one or two paragraphs)! Since this research is a collaborative report across roles, this post is cross-posted on our Customer IntelligenceInteractive Marketing, and Customer Experience role blogs, if you want to see what others may be thinking about.

 

Written by leminhhai

19.11.2009 at 00:41

Posted in marketing

Tagged with ,

An introduction to search commands

leave a comment »

An introduction to search commands

Did you know you can search Google for web pages which were published in a certain timeframe? Did you know it often better to use Yahoo to work out your back links as you can exclude your own internal links?

In Yahoo it is possible to restrict your search to pages which have meta tags or which are in the Mediterranean (the coast, one assumes, rather than the sea). On Live search you can look for pages which contain RSS.

The Search Commands* home page shows summary search commands for: GoogleYahoo and Live Search. The rest of the site takes a deeper look at the nuances of common search commands and digs up some of the more obscure search engine commands too. Search Commands* is in beta.

Google search commands summary

cache:
Show the cached snapshot of a page
link:
List pages which link to a page
related:
List pages which Google consider to be related to another
info:
Find one specific URL in the search database
define:
Show Google’s glossary definition for a term
stocks:
Show American stockmarket information for a given ticker symbol
site:
Restrict a search to a single site
allintitle:
Restrict a search so that all the keywords must appear in the title
intitle:
Restrict a search so that some of the keywords must appear in the title
allintext:
Restrict a search so that all of the keywords must appear in the body text
allinurl:
Restrict a search so that all of the keywords must appear in the page address
inurl:
Restrict a search so that some keywords must appear in the page address
OR
List pages which have at least some of the keywords
+
Insist that the search engine includes a given keyword in the search results
-
Insist that the search engine omits pages which match a given keyword in the search results
~
Enhance a search to include synonyms for a given keyword
*
Include a wildcard match in your search results
[#]…[#]
Search a range of numbers as a keyword
daterange:
Restrict a search to any timeframe
“”
Restrict a search so that the keywords must appear consecutively in a phrase
date:
Restrict a search to a recent timeframe
safesearch:
Restrict a search to exclude adult-content
filetype:
Restrict a search to a given type of file

More information about Google’s search commands is available on the dedicated Google search commands page. In Google’s page we look at how to use each commands, which search commands can be used together and which cannot.

Yahoo search commands summary

site:
Restrict a search to a single site
hostname:
Restrict a search to a single host name
link:
List pages which link to a page
url:
Find one specific URL in the search database
inurl:
Restrict a search so that some keywords must appear in the page address
intitle:
Restrict a search so that some of the keywords must appear in the title
map
Inclue a map of any US location
weather
Include current weatherinformation for any US location
define
Include a defination for the keyword
airport
Link to weather, directions and maps for an American airport
area code
Include a list of cities which match the US area code
facts
Include encyclopedia entry for keyword
convert:
Show a variety of unit conversion rates, for example currency or distance
gas
Include link to gas prices for an American area
hotels
Include links to hotels in the area
showtimes
Include and link to movie showtimes in the area
news
Include and link to news headlines which match the keyword
patent
Link to detailed information for the matching patent number keyword
quote
Show American stockmarket information for a given ticker symbol
synonym
Include synonyms for keyword and link to definitions of each
scores
Include and link to score results for team name keyword
time
Include local time and timezone information for location keyword
traffic
Link to traffic reports for location keyword
zip code
Include a list of zip codes which match the location keyword
+
Insist that the search engine includes a given keyword in the search results
-
Insist that the search engine omits pages which match a given keyword in the search results
feature:
Restrict a search to pages which include a given feature
region:
Restrict a search to pages from a given region

More information about Yahoo’s search commands is available on the dedicated Yahoo search commands page. In Yahoo’s page we look at how to use each commands, which search commands can be used together and which cannot.

Live search commands

filetype:
Restrict a search to a given type of file
link:
List pages which link to a page
linkdomain:
List pages which link to a domain
LinkFromDomain:
List pages which a domain links to
contains:
List pages which link to a given filetype
inurl
Restrict a search so that some keywords must appear in the page address
inanchor:
Restrict a search so that the keyword must appear in anchors tags on the page
intitle:
Restrict a search so that some of the keywords must appear in the title
inbody:
Restrict a search so that all of the keywords must appear in the body text
ip:
List sites hosted by keyword IP address
language:
Restrict a search to a specific language
location:
Restrict a search to pages from a given region
prefer:
Enhance a search by giving emphasis to the given keyword
site:
Restrict a search to a single site
url:
Find one specific URL in the search database
+
Insist that the search engine includes a given keyword in the search results
-
Insist that the search engine omits pages which match a given keyword in the search results
NOT
Insist that the search engine omits pages which match a given keyword in the search results
OR
List pages which have at least some of the keywords
|
List pages which have at least some of the keywords
“”
Restrict a search so that the keywords must appear consecutively in a phrase
()
Group keywords together

More information about Live Search’s search commands is available on the dedicated Live search commands page. In Live Search’s page we look at how to use each commands, which search commands can be used together and which cannot.

Written by leminhhai

17.11.2009 at 04:31

Posted in sem/seo

Tagged with ,

A Tale of Two Nonprofit and Social Media Adoption Surveys

leave a comment »

A Tale of Two Nonprofit and Social Media Adoption Surveys

The results of two new research studies about nonprofits and adoption of social media were released this week.  One focuses on telling nonprofits not to bother with social media, the other provides some strategic ways to move forward.

Weber Shandwick released the results of a survey of 200 nonprofit and foundation executives to explore how their organizations (range of budgets) are using social media and the value they derive from these efforts.   Here’s the topline results:

  • There is extensive experimentation with social media in the nonprofit sector, but only half (51%) surveyed are active users
  • Most nonprofits (67%) say social media is changing how they communicate with broad external audiences, but not narrower categories of stakeholders
  • Most nonprofits (52%) do not currently have the infrastructure, staff and expertise necessary to take full advantage of social media’s potential
  • Nonprofit executives (83%) understand that social media makes it easier for supporters to organize independently – underscoring how critical it is for nonprofits to demonstrate their value and relevance to advocates
  • Ultimately, for most nonprofit executives (79%), the true value of social media has yet to be determined for their organizations

The findings of this research offer insights into how nonprofits and foundations can optimize their use of social media in the future.

Successful nonprofit organizations will:

  • Move from experimentation to implementation of strategic programs that drive digital engagement
  • Focus on two-way conversations that build meaningful and sustainable connections with a range of priority audiences
  • Invest in social media capacity as a means of achieving brand building, advocacy and fundraising goals
  • Demonstrate their unique impact to underscore relevance to advocates
  • Measure social media with key metrics for visibility, engagement and advocacy 

The other survey, implemented by Philanthropy Action, focuses on midsized nonprofits.  The headline is:  Social Network and Mid-Size Nonprofits:  What’s The Use?

The survey looked at results and numbers and concludes that social media is not very effective and that midsize organizations should not waste time or effort.   The survey was implemented between July 2008 and March 2009 – and the results presented here are focused on impact metrics

In terms of fundraising and attracting volunteers, metrics that most nonprofit boards and executive directors highly value, the available evidence suggests that social media is not very effective. To be fair, that evidence is limited. To date, there are only two surveys that we know of, one which we conducted, that have sought to quantify the impact of social technologies in terms familiar to executive directors and boards. In both cases, the results show that social technologies are not delivering much in terms of fundraising or attracting volunteers. While advocates of social technologies rightly point out that these are not the only metrics by which social technologies should be judged, they are the metrics that the majority of respondents to our survey cited as driving their participation. Nonetheless, the overwhelming majority of respondents to our survey say they are going to increase their investment in the use of social networking.

Certainly there are different motivations of the sponsors of these surveys, different methodologies, and different conclusions. 

My opinion is that nonprofits should not ditch their efforts in social media.  It takes time to get results, like anything else.  You need to listen, engagement, develop relationships, scale within your organization, and have the capacity to implement strategically.  This takes time and social media for nonprofits is still in its infancy.  There are no silver bullets.  The results are in developing listeners and participants who may later become supporters.

It’s time to set realistic outcomes, look for strategic efficiencies, and define and share best practices. I don’t think it is a good idea to simply dismiss social media.  I think it is important to have the conversation, but don’t look at ROI in such a narrow – dollars only.   Look at the missed opportunity costs of not participating – as well as take it as an opportunity to look at everything you’re doing and figure out what isn’t working and try social media in its place.  It also important to keep measuring and improving.

What does your nonprofit think?   Social media forget about it or move forward but implement strategically?  Do you think social media is a waste of time for your organization or a technique in the early stages that needs more time to mature?

Update:  The researchers responded that their conclusion was that midsize nonprofits should not use social media for fundraising.  Sure didn’t get that from the title.   Further clarification point:

I think the most interesting “alternative” view of the data we collected is how many orgs reported no success on the metrics that they initially cared about but that they were planning on investing more. There are two possibilities to explain that: 1) they are caught up in shiny object syndrome and thinking “the reason it’s not working is we haven’t invested enough”, or 2) they are finding value other than what they expected and that value is enough to justify increased investment.

This is a point I make over and over again – use the right metrics.   Social media metrics – particularly in the early stages of use – are softer ones – like learning and adapting, and engagement.  Once you’ve engagement full measure, then start counting conversions.

Technorati Tags: ,

Written by leminhhai

16.11.2009 at 15:48

Posted in marketing